In the classical elemental framework, fire was considered one of the four elements alongside earth, air, and water. 1 2 However, in modern science, fire is not considered an element but rather a result of a chemical reaction involving heat, oxygen, and fuel.
Well, this was just a simple answer. But there are few more things to know about this topic which will make your concept super clear.
So let’s dive right into it.
Key Takeaways: Is Fire an Element?
- Fire is not considered an element in modern science because it is not a fundamental substance or a basic building block of matter.
- Fire is a chemical reaction known as combustion, which involves the rapid oxidation of a fuel source in the presence of heat and oxygen.
- Fire is not a distinct state of matter like solids, liquids, gases, or plasmas, but rather an outcome of the interaction between matter and energy.
Why is fire not considered an element in modern science?
In modern science, fire is not considered an element because it is not a fundamental substance or a basic building block of matter. The concept of elements in modern science refers to the fundamental types of atoms that make up all matter in the universe.
The ancient Greeks, including philosophers like Empedocles, proposed the idea that everything in the world was composed of a combination of four elements: 3
- Earth
- Air
- Fire
- Water
This philosophical concept of the elements was based on observable properties of matter at that time.
However, as scientific knowledge advanced, it became clear that matter is composed of atoms, which are the smallest units of an element that retain the chemical properties of that element. 4 Elements are now defined by the number of protons in an atom’s nucleus. 5
Fire, on the other hand, is not an element itself but rather a chemical reaction known as combustion. It involves the rapid oxidation of a fuel source in the presence of heat and oxygen, resulting in the release of light and heat energy. Fire requires the presence of fuel, oxygen, and heat to sustain the chemical reaction. 6
While fire does release energy and can transform matter, it is not an element because it does not have a unique type of atom associated with it. Instead, fire involves the interaction of atoms from the fuel source and oxygen in the air. Therefore, in modern scientific understanding, fire is considered a chemical process rather than an element.
What are the differences between fire and element?
Here’s a table highlighting the few differences between fire and an element:
| Fire | Element |
| Fire is a chemical reaction | Elements are fundamental substances |
| Requires fuel, oxygen, and heat | Defined by the number of protons in an atom’s nucleus |
| Releases light and heat energy | Atoms of an element have unique properties 7 |
| Not a fundamental substance | Elements are the basis of chemical reactions |
| Can vary in intensity and duration | Elements are stable and do not change during chemical reactions |
| Does not have a unique type of atom associated with it | Each element has a distinct type of atom |
Remember, fire is a process involving the rapid oxidation of a fuel source, whereas elements are the fundamental components of matter, defined by the types of atoms they consist of.
Is fire a matter or not?
Since matter can be defined as “anything that occupies space and has mass or weight,” fire does occupy space and has mass due to the gases involved in the combustion process. 8 In that sense, fire can be considered a form of matter. However, it is important to note that fire itself is not a substance or an element like solids, liquids, or gases.
Fire is a transient event or phenomenon that occurs when a fuel undergoes combustion in the presence of oxygen and heat.
The visible flame and the gases emitted during combustion are not a separate substance but rather a result of the chemical reaction. The matter involved in fire, such as the gases and particles, are in a highly energetic and rapidly changing state.
So, while fire can be described as a form of matter due to its occupancy of space and possession of mass, it is not considered a distinct state of matter like solids, liquids, gases, or plasmas.
Fire is an outcome of the interaction between matter and energy rather than a fundamental state of matter itself.
Further reading
Is Evaporation a Physical or Chemical Change?
Is Dissolving a Physical or Chemical change?
Is Boiling Water a Physical or Chemical Change?
Is Water Freezing a Physical or Chemical Change?
Is Wood Burning a Physical or Chemical Change?
Jay is an educator and has helped more than 100,000 students in their studies by providing simple and easy explanations on different science-related topics. He is a founder of Pediabay and is passionate about helping students through his easily digestible explanations.
Read more about our Editorial process.
References
- Classical element – Wikipedia. (2009, January 30). Classical Element – Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_element
- Purdue.edu https://chemed.chem.purdue.edu/genchem/history/aristotle.html
- Empedocles. (n.d.). Empedocles (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/empedocles/
- Mtsu.edu https://www.mtsu.edu/chemistry/chem1010/pdfs/Chapter%202The%20Atom.pdf
- What is an atom ? (n.d.). NRC Web. https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/basic-ref/students/science-101/what-is-an-atom.html
- The Chemistry of Combustion. (n.d.). The Chemistry of Combustion. https://www.chem.fsu.edu/chemlab/chm1020c/Lecture%207/01.php
- Elements and Atoms: The Building Blocks of Matter – Anatomy & Physiology. https://pressbooks-dev.oer.hawaii.edu/anatomyandphysiology/chapter/elements-and-atoms-the-building-blocks-of-matter/
- Austincc.edu https://www.austincc.edu/mreid/CHEM_1405_Chapter_2.PDF
